A common assumption is that spouses want to share their property with each other. This assumption is not always true, however. There are instances in which the couple does not want to automatically share or transfer ownership based solely on the existence of the marriage. More importantly, from a legal perspective, this is not the default arrangement.
Money and property acquired during a marriage are classified as either community property or separate property. This classification is based on two factors: where you live and where the money and property are located.
In community property states, the property obtained during the marriage is, by default, legally classified as belonging to both spouses equally regardless of what the property’s title or deed says. The only cases in which property is not deemed community property in these states is if it was obtained prior to the marriage, obtained during the marriage as an inheritance or gift, obtained during the marriage with money or property from separate property, or its characterization is governed by a pre- or postmarital agreement. There are currently nine community property states: Texas, Arizona, Washington, New Mexico, California, Nevada, Idaho, Wisconsin, and Louisiana.
Money and property that is deemed separate property before marriage retains its characterization unless the spouse commingles the separate property with funds or property acquired from community property. Commingling happens when money and property from one source is mixed with money and property from another source—it is essentially mixing the money together.
The majority of states are considered separate property states (also called common law states). The default characterization in separate property states is that property obtained during the marriage is not automatically deemed community property. Instead, whether money or property is characterized as separate property depends on what the title or deed says. This means that the property belongs to the person who purchased it unless certain other factors exist.
There are also a few states, including Alaska, South Dakota, and Tennessee, that have elective options that allow its residents (and in some cases, even nonresidents) to opt in to a community property system or transfer property into a trust for community property. In addition, some separate property states such as Florida have recently enacted community property trust acts to allow residents to take advantage of certain tax attributes of community property.
Problems that Can Arise
The implications of separate and community property are seen when there is a death or divorce. These life events require the identification and segmentation of property. During a divorce in most states, legal determinations are made about money and property to help ensure equitable distributions of property and money for each person. At the time of a death, the legal determinations are necessary to ensure that inheritances are distributed in an orderly fashion. Issues can occur during death or divorce based on whether you are located in a community property state or separate property state, the expectations of the parties involved, and disagreements that can occur.
Potential Problems in Divorce
Common problems that occur in a divorce arise when one spouse believes that they have an ownership interest in property and their soon-to-be ex-spouse does not agree. Where the couple resides will most likely determine the prevailing party. For example, imagine that a couple acquired a home, two cars, cash that they kept in three accounts, and a few other items during their marriage. Imagine that the wife opened one of the accounts secretly in her name using money she earned from her employment during the marriage. The couple decides to seperate. The husband believes that he should be entitled to a half of the account balance, but the wife disagrees. Who is right? Well, it depends.
The outcome may turn first on where the couple lives. If they live in a community property state such as California, the default rule is that all of the money and property acquired during the course of the marriage, including the wife’s secret account, belongs to each spouse equally. In that case, the husband would be correct. However, in a separate property state such as Georgia, the money in the wife’s secret account would be considered her separate property. But that is not the end of the story. The divorcing couple may still divide the account if they are equitably distributing their money and property during the settlement.
Potential Problems in Death
In addition to issues that arise during divorce, the community property versus separate classification has significant implications when a spouse dies. These issues impact how money and property are transferred as well as who has the ability to access these items. In community property states, money and property acquired during marriage are classified as being jointly owned and will pass to the deceased’s spouse. In separate property states, this transfer is not automatic; i.e., there is no guarantee that the surviving spouse will receive the property of their deceased spouse. It is important to note, however, that many states, regardless of how they classify property, offer spouses a homestead exemption to protect their rights if they are living in the home. These homestead exemptions differ from state to state and have varying outcomes. In addition, most states generally do not allow one spouse to completely disinherit the other.
Some may view the automatic transfer of property to a surviving spouse as a positive outcome. However, consider the following scenarios:
- An estranged couple no longer communicate or cohabitate but have not obtained a divorce. All their friends and family members are aware of the disintegration of their relationship. Eventually, one spouse passes away. In a community property state, the estranged spouse would get control over money and property that the deceased spouse may not have given to them.
- A man with two adult children from a prior relationship marries a woman with no children. His children and his new wife do not get along. He suddenly passes away. In a community property state, absent instructions stating otherwise (i.e. a marital agreement and an estate plan), his wife inherits his accounts and property that are classified as community property, and, contrary to his wishes, he inadvertently blocks his children from receiving any benefit from the community property.
The outcomes in these situations will differ based on the specific state statutes; however, the scenarios reveal the potential conflicts.
Potential Challenges when Moving
The laws regarding how property is categorized differ from state to state. As a result, moving from one state to another must be handled with care and counsel. State law determines how your property will be treated. For example, some community property states allow property to maintain its separate property characteristics if moving from a separate property state, while other community property states do not. On the other hand, when a couple moves from a community property state to a separate property state, the community property retains its status unless other steps are taken.
The most important thing a couple can do to avoid these complexities is communicate with each other and have an experienced estate planning attorney help plan for the unexpected with a comprehensive estate plan. An experienced attorney will help you understand how your state classifies your money and property. Moreover, a carefully drafted estate plan can help you express your wishes regarding how you want your property treated.
If you are married, this is a very important legal concept that you should be aware of. These property classifications and their implications can result in tense situations between not only couples, but other family members as well.